Noise to Signal

Login disabled.

Doctor Who - Doomsday

The Doctor gets up close and personal with a Dalek cultist.
The Doctor gets up close and personal with a Dalek cultist.

For the first 21 years of my life nothing happened, nothing at all, not ever. And then I met a man called The Doctor. A man who could pull huge TV ratings out of his arse. And he took me away from home in his magical machine. He showed me the whole of time and space on primetime BBC One.

I was a little disappointed with series 2. Disappointed with sub standard stories, dodgy acting and poor scripting. I thought the disappointment would never end. That's what I thought. But then came the Army of Ghosts. Then came Torchwood and the war. Then came a fuck load of Cybermen and Daleks and a pant wetting cliffhanger.

And that's when the disappointment ended.

This is the story of how I cried.

Ahem, anyway, sub-standard “jokes” aside, let's address the real issue here. For me, this series has not been as good as the first. Tennant has failed to convince as fully as Eccleston did, Piper descended from a vibrant Time Travelling explorer to a gurning twat and the return of the Cybermen in episodes five and six was disappointing to say the very least. Even Mark Gatiss disappointed to some extent, delivering an episode that could never live up to his Dickensien masterpiece of 2005. That's not to say that series 2 hasn't had its high points, though (Girl in the Fireplace, The Impossible Planet and The Satan Pit, for example).

But, you know, it all comes out in the wash. In this case, it was wash of tears. Just a few, but tears none the less. I cried at the end of this episode (poorly hidden from my fellow Whovians Seb and Ian via the subtle adoption of the Frank Butcher 'eye clasp') for two very good reasons, both of which will become abundantly clear by the end of this review.

So, it's the final episode of series 2. Not only that, but it has the mother of all cliffhangers weighing on its shoulders. A cliffhanger that promises so much and a cliffhanger that was going to be incredibly hard to live up to. For 7 days, fan boys and girls alike have been speculating, pondering and masturbating; each coming up with their own perfect finale in their head. This episode, to put it mildly, had quite a job to do.

And that's before you consider the other thing. By the end of this episode, an episode featuring the Daleks and Cybermen coming toe to pepperpot for the first time ever, Russell T Davies had to write out one of Who's most loved companions to date. The story of Rose Tyler's death was going to have to jostle for position with the Cybermen and the Daleks and, somehow, both these story threads were going to have to co-exist together without one suffocating under the weight of the other.

So, was this pulled off? Did RTD actually manage to write the two biggest story threads of new Who's life and execute them nicely within his 45 minute time-frame? Oh God, yes. Yes, he bloody well did indeed.

Something that was obvious from last year's finale is that RT Davies can write Dalek dialogue like no other man. “WHAT IS THE MEANING OF THIS NEGATIVE?”, “DO NOT BLASHPHEME”, “HAIL THE DOCTOR, THE GREAT EXTERMINATOR” are three that leap instantly to mind. However, the rantings of several hundred thousand Daleks and their fruit loop Emperor pale in comparison to the sublime Dalek/Cyberman pissing contest witnessed in Doomsday. Chuckle away to yourself as The Daleks and Cybermen both insist on the other introducing themselves first, howl with delight as The Cybermen counter that Dalek statement “WE HAVE NO CONCEPT OF ELEGANCE” with the pearler “This Is Obvious” and shriek with glee as The Daleks confidentially predict the demise of the Cybermen as being no more than “PEST CONTROL”. I did all that, and more, and for the simple reason that Russell TD judged the tone of the dialogue perfectly. It was funny, it was spine tingling, it was dramatic and, above all, it felt so realistic and right.

In a wholly surprising move, he got the mix of humour absolutely spot on with not a single clunky word making an awful noise and ruining the beauty of these exchanges. R Terrance (I expect) D has gained a not very desirable reputation among some fans (myself included) of being a tad misguided at times, with pop culture references and bad jokes often getting in the way of a nice moment. However, every last line uttered by our lovable Metal Bastards was an undiluted joy to hear.

So, anyway, that cliffhanger. We knew the Daleks would have to be foiled pretty quickly, in order to stop Rose, Mickey and Dr. Whatsit getting deaded, and I loved the way it was resolved. The Dalek's only real weakness (mentally, at least) seems to be their infinite curiosity and desire to gain an advantage from other people or races. When Rose revealed herself to be more than some normal piece of disruptor fodder, they couldn't help but let her stick around, in order for them to find out how this cocky cockney knows them and maybe speed along the opening of the Genesis Ark. It was a very satisfying conclusion to the cliffhanger for being simple yet consistent with the Daleks' known traits. Make yourself useful and they're bound to spare you. For a while, at least.

Frankly, London doesn't stand a chance.
Frankly, London doesn't stand a chance.

Now, the Genesis Ark. In hindsight it seems obvious that Davies, Russell T had whacked a huge great bluff on us when we first encountered this device in last week's preview. Any self respecting Who fan will instantly jump to the conclusion (initially, at least) that everyone's favourite be-chaired maniac will be housed inside. In fact, I held that suspicion right up until the last minute, with the confident prediction that the end of the episode would reveal Davros, in order to set up a Mexican Stand-off between him and The Doctor for the Christmas Special. But, you know, I was wrong. And I'm glad I was wrong. The slow reveal of the true nature of the device (and the mystery was kept *just* long enough to have you panting with anticipation when it finally opened) was perfectly judged – especially the moment when we learn of its Time Lordy origins.

With all this going on it could be very easy to forget about the man himself: The Doctor. In a way it was disappointing that his first encounter with The Daleks was through a laptop and a mobile phone, and it would have been great to have him in the thick of it right from the start. However, the image of The Doctor quietly shitting himself when the Cybermen proposed the alliance with the Daleks was most rewarding.

Still, the inevitable soon happens and The Doctor finally gets his chance to flap about in front of his old foes, generally causing them annoyance. This, again, was a brilliant scene with The Doctor being both hilarious and serious in equal measure. All too often this series we've seen him being far too hyperactive, so it was a nice chance to see him laying off the E numbers a little for this scene. Once again, we're reminded of the Time Lords and the Time War, confirming somewhat that this could be quite a long running arc with, hopefully, one spectacular pay-off soon. The Time Lords *have* to come back and this little reminder of their extinction must serve some sort of purpose in the short term... Speaking of mythology, too, I find it interesting that Skaro (the Dalek homeworld) has finally been mentioned by name (unlike Gallifrey) - along with The Cult of Skaro, the little secret society from which our Dalek chums come from. I'd like to think this is some groundwork laying for a future encounter with the Cult, or maybe an adventure on Skaro itself. We know one thing for sure, though, and that is we will see the black Dalek again, once we find out where he temporal shifted his ass to.

Anyway, after a gorgeous ruckus between the Daleks and the Cybs in Torchwood tower, the Ark is opened up and all hell breaks loose in the form of millions of previously imprisoned Daleks. Not only that, but the Cybs are on their own manoeuvres, too. Oh buggering shit. This does bring me on to one slight mis-giving about the episode, though, as I don't think nearly enough time was given to the invasion, to allow it to hit home properly. In The Parting of the Ways, the invasion was suggested and left mainly to our imaginations and the briefness of the coverage suited that perfectly. However, when you've got countless Cybermen battling countless Daleks, both of whom want the human race for something completely different, I feel it could have had more justice done to it if it was longer. Maybe even the main focus for the second of a three part story... At least we wouldn't have had to endure Fear Her.

But, as problems go, it's a pretty minor one and it certainly doesn't detract from the style the invasion was carried out with. Consisting of long shots in the main, the CGI stays effective and believable throughout, with the sheer scale of the thing realised beautifully. Never will I forget the image of several million Daleks soaring over London in square, Roman like regiments – ready to bulldozer the whole place. Brilliant.

So, how about that pesky human story that needs to be squeezed in there, then? Well, there's certainly plenty to get in, seeming as we have to cover the exit of Rose and the rest of her 'gang'.

We have Jackie coming dangerously close to being cyberised (again) before meeting with the alternate Pete (in, what has to be a said, is a lovely scene) and we've got the Canny Geordie Fella and his gang of crazees jumping across voids like there's no tomorrow – all of which is nicely doing the groundwork for the big exit.

And, blimey, what a great exit it was. Unsurprisingly, The Doctor is faced with one helluva decision to make on the fly (as should always be the way). He has one way to eject the Daleks and Cybs out of his world, but the only way he can do that is to risk sacrificing his life and banish Rose to the alternate universe forever, in order to save hers. In true Doctor style this quite Earth shattering fact is seemingly brushed aside with zero emotion. Until, that is, the reality hits him. Rose returns, defiant as ever, and helps the Doctor to suck the invaders out through the 'door' and into the hellish void (which, by the way, was a lovely sequence showing once again that CG can be done in such a convincing way, even on Who's TV budget) – but she is only narrowly saved from the gaping hole by hero of the hour Pete Tyler, who zooms back just in time to carry her to the safety of Alternate Earth. And then she's gone. And the Doctor is alone again.

Bye bye, then :(
Bye bye, then :(

Cry No. 1: The Lengthy Goodbye

Rose Tyler is gone. Jackie Tyler is gone. Mickey Smith is gone. The three most enduring characters of the new series have gone. Just like that. When Christopher Eccleston hung up his battered leather jacket, the show, by and large, didn't change too much. The Doctor is still the Doctor and we had a fine actor to take his place and keep the momentum going. However. For 27 episodes we've been told the story of Rose Tyler and her family. It has essentially been the very bread and butter of the whole show. And now they've all gone, and the show will have to carry on with them. It's going to have to change.

I could never have expected being so moved by the departure of these characters (non of whom I was particularly convinced with a lot of the time), but when I realised how much they've been integral to the show and how different it's going to be from now on, I couldn't help but be affected.

Neither, it seems, could The Doctor. Davies, Russell T (RTD for short) was not afraid to make the aftermath of Rose's disappearance last as long as possible, letting each note of Murray Gold's perfect score ingrain itself in to your battered soul as you soak up the ramifications of what you've just seen. Yet, there's more to come, as The Doctor finds a yet unsealed crack and allows himself a final goodbye at the expense of a sun. A beautiful and quiet scene on a beach in Norway is the setting for the final goodbye, and with a one-sided “I love you” she's gone. And so concluded the perfect exit for the Tylers and Mickey. Perfect. Bye Rose, we'll miss your oddly beautiful face.

Cry No. 2: Was That Fucking Catherine Tate?

Hmmmm. After what could well be 44.5 minutes of pure, perfect television, to be greeted with this 'cliffhanger' was a certainly an interesting experience. Consider this reviewer most certainly bovvered with this piece of stunt casting. But, that's all I'll say on the matter, as I'm sure there'll be plenty to say come Christmas time.

As you may have guessed, this is a 5 Star episode without any shadow of a doubt. It's the closest Who has come to perfection since the start of the new series, and I'm delighted we've ended on such a positive note.

See you all for Torchwood in the autumn.

5 Stars

About this entry


Comments

Not as good as The Parting Of The Ways, but still pretty good. Before I saw Doomsday I prayed that we wouldn't get another situation of thousands of Daleks being everywhere only for them to be defeated in simple 'push a button' (or in this case pull a lever) fashion. Sadly that's what we got. I MUCH preferred the idea that the 4 Daleks of the Cult of Skaro could take on the 5 million Cybermen and win because they're THAT good. That was a bit of a spine-tingling moment. But then the thousands of Daleks flying out of the Ark didn't feel necessary at all. The whole situation suddenly became less threatening and interesting because you KNEW they weren't going to last longer than 5 minutes.

This war really needed an episode on it's own. It was definitely short-changed in favour of Rose's story, which granted was excellent. I thought the beach scene was brilliant. The Catherine Tate Runaway Bride cliffhanger kind of fucked things up though. The Doctor should have been on his own for a while. Series 3 better be better than series 2. Pointer 1 - get Joe Ahearne back. Pointer 2 - stop being so 'this is the great BBC success Doctor Who' smug. Pointer 3 - PLAN PLAN PLAN the series better. Rein in the hack writers (or fire them).

By performingmonkey
July 12, 2006 @ 7:31 pm

reply / #


Another disappointment as it couldn't quite live up to the hype of the last ten minutes. The Daleks and the Cybermen were both dealt with far too easily and Rose's rescue at the hands of her 'father' was waaaaay to convenient.

And Catherine Tate? BUGGER OFF.

By Pete Martin
July 12, 2006 @ 8:34 pm

reply / #


Fucking hell, what the Jesusing shit do you people want?

By Cappsy
July 12, 2006 @ 9:14 pm

reply / #


Now thats an introduction... and thats how who should be. Apart from Catherine Tate, that is.

By Spid
July 12, 2006 @ 9:42 pm

reply / #


Man, Catherine Tate on Christmas Day. Dearie me.

Anyway,4/5. Agree with what was said in first two comments.

By Rad
July 12, 2006 @ 10:04 pm

reply / #


'For the first 21 years of my life nothing happened, nothing at all, not ever. And then I met a man called The Doctor. A man who could pull huge TV ratings out of his arse. And he took me away from home in his magical machine. He showed me the whole of time and space on primetime BBC One. I was a little disappointed with series 2. Disappointed with sub standard stories, dodgy acting and poor scripting. I thought the disappointment would never end. That's what I thought. But then came the Army of Ghosts. Then came Torchwood and the war. Then came a fuck load of Cybermen and Daleks and a pant wetting cliffhanger. And that's when the disappointment ended. This is the story of how I cried.'

You know if you'd sent that as a letter to the Doctor Who Magazine I would really hate you. It's fine here though. : )

By Rad
July 12, 2006 @ 10:06 pm

reply / #


Great review Cappsy, I totally agree with it - for a series that's mostly had me rolling my eyes, this was a surprisingly gut-wrenching finale that really knew how to hit the emotional beats. Some of it was a bit over-convenient (and I'm thinking of Pete the Teleporting Ninja here) but when the characters are being written that well, the minor plot holes fade far enough into the background that I don't really get too obsessive over the mechanics. And yeah, that initial Dalek/Cyberman standoff was brilliant. After that "Dalek's do not take orders!" line I was half-expecting the cyberman to go "Ha, so you're Daleks then, are you?"

By James H
July 12, 2006 @ 11:04 pm

reply / #


>Fucking hell, what the Jesusing shit do you people want?

Funnier, smarter, more consistent, better acted...In a nutshell; Buffy the Vampire Slayer.

By Pete Martin
July 13, 2006 @ 7:47 am

reply / #


But Doctor Who isn't Buffy. For all the shared influence, they're two different shows aimed at different audiences.

To say you want Buffy when discussing Who is like ordering a pizza and then sending it back because it isn't a curry.

By Seb Patrick
July 13, 2006 @ 8:47 am

reply / #


IMHO, Buffy is the type of show that Doctor Who should aspire to be. Ok, so it doesn't need to be as dark but it obviously tries hard (and too often fails) to be funny while it's trying hard (and too often failing) to be scary.

Of course, if they stuck Buffy on Saturday nights on BBC 1, it would hopelessly struggle in the ratings. And to its credit, there's very few sci-fi shows I sit down and watch any more. However, I'm very rarely fully satisfied with an episode of Who. There are always aspects that jar with me; whether its the infantile humour or the sheer cheese of it all.

I guess I just prefer curry. Pizza is nice occasionally though...

By Pete Martin
July 13, 2006 @ 9:17 am

reply / #


Here you are, guys:

By Ian Symes
July 13, 2006 @ 11:18 am

reply / #


The best bit was the Dalek tribute to "Don't tell him Pike !"

By Andy M
July 13, 2006 @ 11:54 am

reply / #


By the same token, I think Lost is rubbish because it hasn't got Daleks in it.

By Seb
July 13, 2006 @ 11:55 am

reply / #


I think Doctor Who is great because it hasn't got Michelle Rodriguez in it.

By Andy M
July 13, 2006 @ 12:26 pm

reply / #


Here is a list of other people whose absence makes Doctor Who great :

1. Davina McCall
2. Ken Dodd
3. Helen Worth
4. Catherine Tate
5. Bonnie Langford

Oh hang on...

By Andy M
July 13, 2006 @ 12:30 pm

reply / #


By the same token, I think Lost is rubbish because it hasn't got Daleks in it.

Not seen the season 2 finale yet, then?

Oops, spoilers.

By Cappsy
July 13, 2006 @ 2:19 pm

reply / #


Cappsy : that may well have made more sense.

By Andy M
July 13, 2006 @ 6:24 pm

reply / #


> Here you are, guys.

Thanks. Now, was that too much to ask?

By Pete Martin
July 13, 2006 @ 7:23 pm

reply / #


No second opinion?!

By Geoff
July 15, 2006 @ 5:09 pm

reply / #


When Rose's Dad materialised to rescue her, why wasn't he sucked into the void *before* her? He just seemed able to stand still and catch her - how come?

By Geoff
July 17, 2006 @ 11:46 am

reply / #


Relative amounts of void stuff, inertia, blah blah blah.

By Seb
July 17, 2006 @ 12:21 pm

reply / #


Oh, and someone - Ian, I think - was meant to do a second opinion, but just never got round to it. I think Cappsy's review expressed most of what most of us wanted to say about the ep, anyway.

By Seb
July 17, 2006 @ 12:21 pm

reply / #


Yeah, it was my fault - I went away for a couple of days after the show, and by the time I got back we couldn't hold the review off any longer.

By Ian Symes
July 17, 2006 @ 2:08 pm

reply / #


We didn't do a secon opinion for Fear Her, either. But that was for very different reasons...

By Cappsy
July 17, 2006 @ 2:12 pm

reply / #


"Relative amounts of void stuff, inertia, blah blah blah."

NOT AN ACCEPTABLE REASONS.

By Geoff
July 17, 2006 @ 4:28 pm

reply / #


No, but seriously. It's obvious that the more times you've been through the breach, the more "void stuff" you have on you, so the more likely you are to get sucked through (which is why the Daleks, who've been hiding in the void for ages, get sucked in from miles away, likewise the Cybermen). Pete has - we assume from what we've seen onscreen only made two trips - once there and back, both within the episode. Therefore, when he makes the trip to save Rose, he's less susceptible to the breach. He'd be pulled in eventually, but he's got enough time to grab her and get out again.

A bigger plothole is how he KNOWS to show up and save her, but let's not go there...

By Seb
July 17, 2006 @ 4:50 pm

reply / #


What obviously should have happened is for Doctor Who to tell Billie to stay holding onto that thing instead of trying to fix the lever, and just fixed it with his Sonic Screwdriver. Because it can do anything.

By Michael Lacey
July 18, 2006 @ 6:59 am

reply / #


"Therefore, when he makes the trip to save Rose, he's less susceptible to the breach"

But not less susceptible than Rose who's only been through once and come back. She was shooting towards it like a dart, while he just stood there like Al from Quantum Leap, completely unaffected.

"A bigger plothole is how he KNOWS to show up and save her, but let's not go there..."

The thing was she had to be saved, and I have no issue with that. I'm just cross because they made yet another convenient resolution out of it, as if the makers of this series are addicted to the damn things. It didn't NEED that this time!

By Geoff
July 18, 2006 @ 3:19 pm

reply / #


Just watched this when I got back from holiday. All fine and dandy, a bit cheesy for me, I think they could have stopped when the Doc and Rose were leaning against the "same" wall and then he walked away.... but why didnt the newly created Cybermen, like Hartman, get left behind? They'd never been though the void...

By Jess
July 19, 2006 @ 5:19 pm

reply / #


> but why didnt the newly created Cybermen, like Hartman, get left behind?

Maybe they did stay behind, for the same reason the black dalek performed an emergency temporal shift - so they can return in later episodes.

By Jake Monkeyson
July 19, 2006 @ 6:10 pm

reply / #


> why didnt the newly created Cybermen, like Hartman, get left behind? They'd never been though the void...

Because their SUITS had

By Somebody
July 19, 2006 @ 11:41 pm

reply / #


I personally don't want all future cybermen to be from that alternative dimension, with fucking personality/emotion inhibitor chips waiting to be tripped with a mobile phone whenever there happens to be a handy slot nearby. And I pray that future branches of cybermen don't stem from remains discovered of this batch.

Future cybermen should have upgraded voluntarily like our original kind, and be properly weapon resistant so we have no clue how they'll be defeated. And not have some other kind of ridiculous achilles heel tucked away. I agree with the person who said cybermen should come as close to the terminator as possible in their relentless nature and apparent indestructability. To be honest I found the cybermen to be such a minor threat in this series, especially the final episode (where they were shown being blown up left right and centre) that I'm not that excited by the prospect of seeing this same incarnation return any time in the future.

By Geoff
July 20, 2006 @ 11:41 am

reply / #


hi im mia and i am the biggest doctor who fan ever but im only 10 and i cryed at the end when rose went, it was so sad!
i didn't want billie piper to leave doctor who!
any way im gong to go
by by
xxxxx

By mia
October 31, 2006 @ 7:06 pm

reply / #


Guessing possibly you might be an adult male with something wrong with you. Still never mind, "by by".

By Ray
November 01, 2006 @ 9:56 pm

reply / #


i just watched this on sunday the 29th novemer 06.
i thourt it was mint when the cybermen and the darlaks have a great fight but my favourite part was when rose see's through the 3D glasses. i did'nt like it when rose went into a nother world. i cry every time i see it on computer or t.v. bye-bye for now.
jessica

p.s. i love ***** *******. i relly do all though you dont know who it is or do you.

By jessica smith
November 24, 2006 @ 8:14 pm

reply / #


i just watched this on sunday the 23rd novemer 06.
i thourt it was mint when the cybermen and the darlaks have a great fight but my favourite part was when rose see's through the 3D glasses. i did'nt like it when rose went into a nother world. i cry every time i see it on computer or t.v. bye-bye for now.
jessica

p.s. i love ***** *******. i relly do all though you dont know who it is or do you.

By jessica smith
November 24, 2006 @ 8:14 pm

reply / #


Hello, Jazz.

By Jonathan Capps
November 24, 2006 @ 10:22 pm

reply / #


"Hazz".

By Seb
November 25, 2006 @ 12:04 am

reply / #


You all are too picky. I think the ending was beautiful. A fantastic piece of writing from Russel T Davis. FANTASTIC!!!

By Bec
June 12, 2007 @ 10:39 am

reply / #